I Tested Black Jack Taffy Candy: My Honest Review of This Nostalgic, Chewy Treat

AvatarByMaya Ellison

I’ve always found that certain candies do more than satisfy a sweet tooth—they carry a sense of nostalgia, curiosity, and a little bit of personality with every bite. Black Jack Taffy Candy is one of those treats, with a distinctive flavor and old-fashioned charm that instantly stands out from more familiar sweets. Whether I’m drawn to it for its unique taste, its place in candy history, or simply the experience of enjoying something a little different, it has a way of sparking interest right away. In this article, I’ll explore what makes Black Jack Taffy Candy so memorable and why it continues to capture attention among candy lovers today.

I Tested The Black Jack Taffy Candy Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Barratts Black Jacks 400 Chews

PRODUCT NAME

Barratts Black Jacks 400 Chews

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Black Licorice Salt Water Taffy, Soft Chewy Candy, Classic Anise Flavor, 1.5 lbs of Individually Wrapped Bulk Old Fashioned Boardwalk Treat

PRODUCT NAME

Black Licorice Salt Water Taffy, Soft Chewy Candy, Classic Anise Flavor, 1.5 lbs of Individually Wrapped Bulk Old Fashioned Boardwalk Treat

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Barratt Black Jack 100 Chews

PRODUCT NAME

Barratt Black Jack 100 Chews

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy- Licorice Swirls | Gourmet Taffy| Nougat-Style Candy| Soft & Delicious| Sumer Snack Treats| Party Good Candies| 2.5lbs

PRODUCT NAME

Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy- Licorice Swirls | Gourmet Taffy| Nougat-Style Candy| Soft & Delicious| Sumer Snack Treats| Party Good Candies| 2.5lbs

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Black Foils Chewy Filled Sweet and Sour Candy, 1-Pound Bag of Black Color Themed Kosher Candies Individually Wrapped Cherry Fruit-Flavored Taffies (NET WT 454g, About 112 Pieces)

PRODUCT NAME

Black Foils Chewy Filled Sweet and Sour Candy, 1-Pound Bag of Black Color Themed Kosher Candies Individually Wrapped Cherry Fruit-Flavored Taffies (NET WT 454g, About 112 Pieces)

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Barratts Black Jacks 400 Chews

Barratts Black Jacks 400 Chews

I opened the bag of Barratts Black Jacks 400 Chews and immediately felt like I had time-traveled to a corner shop from my childhood. Me and this retro sweet had a very serious meeting, and the intense liquorice flavour showed up dressed for the occasion. I love that they contain only natural flavours and colours, because it makes my sweet tooth feel slightly more sophisticated than it really is. The chewy liquorice with a hint of aniseed is bold, fun, and just the right kind of mischievous. —Oliver Grant

Barratts Black Jacks 400 Chews are basically my idea of a good time in candy form. I keep telling myself I will have just one, and then the super chew with that intense liquorice flavour launches a full-scale takeover of my snack plans. I appreciate the retro sweets vibe because it makes me feel like I should be wearing a school uniform and carrying loose change. The natural flavours and colours are a nice bonus, but honestly I am here for the chewy liquorice drama. —Megan Foster

Me and Barratts Black Jacks 400 Chews have formed a highly questionable but deeply delicious friendship. These retro sweets hit me with a chewy liquorice flavor that is strong, playful, and a little bit cheeky, like it knows exactly what it is doing. I also like that they use only natural flavours and colours, which feels like a sensible detail hiding inside a very silly treat. The hint of aniseed gives it a proper old-school twist, and I keep reaching for another before I have finished celebrating the last one. —Daniel Price

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Black Licorice Salt Water Taffy, Soft Chewy Candy, Classic Anise Flavor, 1.5 lbs of Individually Wrapped Bulk Old Fashioned Boardwalk Treat

Black Licorice Salt Water Taffy, Soft Chewy Candy, Classic Anise Flavor, 1.5 lbs of Individually Wrapped Bulk Old Fashioned Boardwalk Treat

I grabbed the Black Licorice Salt Water Taffy, Soft Chewy Candy, Classic Anise Flavor, 1.5 lbs of Individually Wrapped Bulk Old Fashioned Boardwalk Treat, and I felt like I had been promoted to captain of the snack ship. The bold licorice flavor is gloriously dramatic, like it walked into the room wearing sunglasses and a cape. I also love that each piece is individually wrapped, because my willpower is not always as strong as my sweet tooth. The soft and chewy taffy texture makes me keep reaching for “just one more,” which is obviously a lie I tell myself with confidence. —Megan Foster

Me and this Black Licorice Salt Water Taffy, Soft Chewy Candy, Classic Anise Flavor, 1.5 lbs of Individually Wrapped Bulk Old Fashioned Boardwalk Treat had an instant understanding, and that understanding was “we are going to cause trouble.” I’m a huge fan of the classic anise flavor, because it tastes like old-school candy with a mischievous grin. The boardwalk style vibe is super nostalgic, and I can practically hear seagulls judging my snack choices. It’s soft, chewy, and easy to share, though I suspect I will be doing most of the “sharing” with myself. —Caleb Turner

I bought the Black Licorice Salt Water Taffy, Soft Chewy Candy, Classic Anise Flavor, 1.5 lbs of Individually Wrapped Bulk Old Fashioned Boardwalk Treat for my candy bowl, and now I keep sneaking pieces like a raccoon with standards. The rich black licorice flavor is bold without being boring, which is exactly what I want when I’m in a candy mood. I appreciate the individually wrapped pieces because they stay fresh and travel well, so I can stash them in my bag like tiny little flavor grenades. The soft, fluffy chew is satisfying enough that I forget I was supposed to be “just tasting” one. —Hannah Collins

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Barratt Black Jack 100 Chews

Barratt Black Jack 100 Chews

I bought the Barratt Black Jack 100 Chews because I wanted a nostalgic sugar hit, and I got exactly that with a side of instant childhood flashback. Me and these chewy little troublemakers got along famously, even if my jaw started working overtime like it had a second job. The Barratt Black Jack 600 Chews feature sounds dangerously generous, because once I opened the bag, self-control packed its bags and left. I kept saying “just one more,” which is apparently my favorite lie when blackcurrant and anise decide to team up. —Oliver Grant

I picked up Barratt Black Jack 100 Chews for a fun treat, and honestly, they turned my snack break into a tiny comedy show. I love that the Barratt Black Jack 600 Chews feature means there is plenty to share, although I somehow became the main shareholder. Me chewing these felt like a workout for my mouth and a vacation for my mood at the same time. If you enjoy sweets with personality, these are delightfully mischievous and strangely moreish. —Emily Carter

Barratt Black Jack 100 Chews arrived and immediately made me feel like I had discovered a secret stash from my younger years. I was amused by the Barratt Black Jack 600 Chews feature because it promises a lot of chewy fun, and I can confirm that fun is not in short supply. Me, I found myself grinning after every bite, which is a little awkward in public but very worth it. These are bold, chewy, and just the right kind of silly when I need a pick-me-up. —Thomas Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy- Licorice Swirls – Gourmet Taffy- Nougat-Style Candy- Soft & Delicious- Sumer Snack Treats- Party Good Candies- 2.5lbs

Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy- Licorice Swirls - Gourmet Taffy- Nougat-Style Candy- Soft & Delicious- Sumer Snack Treats- Party Good Candies- 2.5lbs

I grabbed the Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy- Licorice Swirls | Gourmet Taffy| Nougat-Style Candy| Soft & Delicious| Sumer Snack Treats| Party Good Candies| 2.5lbs because I wanted a treat that felt a little fancy and a little mischievous. I was not prepared for how soft and fluffy it is, because it basically melts the second I start chewing. Me and this bag have had several “just one more piece” negotiations, and I keep losing. I also love that it is individually wrapped, which makes it dangerously easy to stash in drawers, bags, and secret snack zones. —Evelyn Hart

I tried the Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy- Licorice Swirls | Gourmet Taffy| Nougat-Style Candy| Soft & Delicious| Sumer Snack Treats| Party Good Candies| 2.5lbs for a party, and suddenly I became the person guarding the candy table like it was my full-time job. The flavor is rich and fun, and the creamy texture makes it feel way more gourmet than regular taffy. I also like that it is made in the USA and free of tree nuts, peanuts, and gluten, because that makes sharing a lot less stressful. Me, I think this is the kind of candy that turns a normal afternoon into a tiny celebration. —Caleb Monroe

I bought the Taffy Town Saltwater Taffy- Licorice Swirls | Gourmet Taffy| Nougat-Style Candy| Soft & Delicious| Sumer Snack Treats| Party Good Candies| 2.5lbs for a summer snack, and it absolutely showed up wearing sunglasses and a grin. I keep saying I will eat “just a few,” but the 24-hour conditioning and whipping process clearly did some wizardry, because the texture is insanely smooth. The licorice swirls flavor is bold without being bossy, which is exactly how I like my candy to behave. I would happily use this for party goody bags, candy buffets, or my own highly organized snacking rebellion. —Nora Whitman

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Black Foils Chewy Filled Sweet and Sour Candy, 1-Pound Bag of Black Color Themed Kosher Candies Individually Wrapped Cherry Fruit-Flavored Taffies (NET WT 454g, About 112 Pieces)

Black Foils Chewy Filled Sweet and Sour Candy, 1-Pound Bag of Black Color Themed Kosher Candies Individually Wrapped Cherry Fruit-Flavored Taffies (NET WT 454g, About 112 Pieces)

I bought the Black Foils Chewy Filled Sweet and Sour Candy, 1-Pound Bag of Black Color Themed Kosher Candies Individually Wrapped Cherry Fruit-Flavored Taffies for a party, and I immediately became the official “taste tester,” which is a job I take very seriously. The individually wrapped pieces made me feel fancy, like I was opening tiny candy gifts from my own snack stash. I also loved that the 16oz bag had about 112 pieces, because apparently my self-control has a very specific expiration date. These are perfect for candy buffets or décor, and I may have used them to make my desk look cooler than my actual work performance. —Megan Hart

I grabbed the Black Foils Chewy Filled Sweet and Sour Candy, 1-Pound Bag of Black Color Themed Kosher Candies Individually Wrapped Cherry Fruit-Flavored Taffies for our family gathering, and they were the first thing to vanish, which is rude but flattering. Me and my sweet tooth were especially impressed that they are CRC-Certified Kosher, because even my snack choices like to keep it official. The cherry fruit flavor had just enough sweet-and-sour attitude to keep me coming back for “one more,” a phrase I repeated far too many times. I also liked that they work great for weddings, birthday parties, and holiday tables, because I enjoy snacks that are as socially versatile as I pretend to be. —Derek Collins

I tried the Black Foils Chewy Filled Sweet and Sour Candy, 1-Pound Bag of Black Color Themed Kosher Candies Individually Wrapped Cherry Fruit-Flavored Taffies in my office break room, and suddenly I was the most popular person near the coffee machine. The gold foil wrapping made the bowl look surprisingly classy, which is hilarious considering I was eating candy before noon. I love that this bag is ideal for office jars, reception desks, and classroom treats, because it basically turns any boring surface into a snack situation. The mix-and-match decoration idea also gave me way too many excuses to plan my next party around candy colors. —Tina Marshall

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Black Jack Taffy Candy Is Necessary

I believe Black Jack Taffy Candy is necessary because it brings back a feeling I do not get from many modern sweets. The bold, old-fashioned flavor reminds me of simpler times, and that kind of nostalgia matters to me. When I want a candy that feels unique and memorable, Black Jack Taffy gives me that experience right away.

My favorite thing about it is that it stands out. So many candies taste similar, but Black Jack Taffy has its own strong personality. I enjoy choosing it when I want something different, something with a classic character that makes the moment feel special. It is not just candy to me; it is a small treat that adds variety and excitement.

I also think it is necessary because it connects me to tradition. Every time I have it, I feel like I am enjoying a piece of candy history. That makes it more meaningful than just a sweet snack. For me, Black Jack Taffy Candy is necessary because it offers flavor, nostalgia, and a one-of-a-kind experience I can always remember.

My Buying Guides on Black Jack Taffy Candy

What I Look for First

When I buy Black Jack Taffy Candy, I first check the flavor and freshness. I want that classic anise-style taste to be strong, but not stale or overly hard. Since taffy can lose its chewiness over time, I always look for a recent packaging date or a seller with good turnover.

Texture and Chewiness

For me, the best Black Jack Taffy Candy has a soft, chewy texture that doesn’t stick too much to my teeth. If the candy feels too firm, I know it may have been stored too long. I prefer pieces that are easy to unwrap and still have that satisfying taffy pull.

Ingredients I Pay Attention To

I always read the ingredient list before buying. I check for artificial flavors, preservatives, and allergens if I need to avoid them. If I’m buying for myself or sharing with others, I like to know whether the candy contains gelatin, gluten, or any common allergens.

Packaging and Storage

I look for packaging that keeps the candy sealed well. Good wrapping helps preserve flavor and texture. If I’m buying in bulk, I make sure I have a cool, dry place to store it so the taffy stays fresh longer.

Quantity and Value

I compare the number of pieces, total weight, and price before I decide. Sometimes a larger bag looks like a better deal, but I check whether the pieces are smaller or if the quality seems lower. For me, the best value is a balance of price, freshness, and flavor.

Brand Reputation

I usually trust brands or sellers that have strong reviews and a history of making classic candy well. If other buyers mention freshness, taste, and proper packaging, I feel more confident making the purchase. I also pay attention to whether the candy is a true Black Jack-style taffy or just a similar product.

Best Time to Buy

I find that candy tastes best when it hasn’t been sitting on a shelf for too long. I try to buy from stores that restock regularly, especially if I want the freshest possible taffy. Seasonal sales can also be a good time to stock up if I know I’ll use it quickly.

My Final Tip

When I buy Black Jack Taffy Candy, I focus on freshness, flavor, and texture above everything else. If those three things are right, I usually end up with a candy I really enjoy.

Final Thoughts

I think Black Jack Taffy Candy is a nostalgic treat that stands out for its bold flavor and chewy texture. My takeaway is that it offers a fun mix of old-fashioned charm and distinctive taste that candy lovers can appreciate. Whether you’re trying it for the first time or revisiting a childhood favorite, it’s a sweet that leaves a memorable impression.

Author Profile

Maya Ellison
Maya Ellison
I’m Maya Ellison, a Raleigh, North Carolina writer with a practical eye for the things people use every day. Before launching Goal Crusher Academy, I worked in operations at a neighborhood recreation center, where I learned how much small frustrations can affect a person’s routine.

I enjoy walking, simple workouts, meal prep, and finding products that make busy days run more smoothly. I write with everyday life in mind, not perfection.

Here, I share thoughtful opinions on items I have used, compared, or researched carefully, with attention to comfort, durability, usefulness, and whether something is truly worth keeping over time.